Have you heard about the 3M Earplug Lawsuit? Thousands of veterans and active service members have filed a 3M Earplug lawsuit against 3M, claiming that the company’s earplugs had defects and caused hearing damage from loud sounds on the battlefield or during training exercises.
On August 29, 2023, according to the plaintiffs lawyers and the company itself, 3M agreed to pay $6.01 billion to settle the lawsuits. After some back and forth, the case developed into one of the largest mass tort cases in U.S history. Both sides had won verdicts and negotiations appeared to be at a standstill, until 3M unsuccessful attempt to move the lawsuits to bankruptcy court.
The case focused on Combat Arms earplugs, which were utilized by the U.S. military in training and combat from 2003 and 2015 in Afghanistan and Iraq. The plaintiffs alleged that the company hid design flaws, faked test results, and failed to provide instructions for using the earplugs properly, all of which led to hearing impairment.
History of 3M Earplug Lawsuit:
Aearo Technologies Inc. and its parent company, 3M Company, manufactured and supplied combat Arms earplugs to the US military from 2003 to 2015 to protect service members ears from the loud sounds that come with war and military training. During those ears, soldiers deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan received this as standard equipment. In 2015 earplugs production ceased without a recall.
In 2016, a competitor based in California, Moldex-Metric, Inc., filed a whistleblower lawsuit against 3M alleging that the company had been selling earplugs that were defective and did not adhere to government protection standards. According to the lawsuit, because of the usage of the faulty earplugs, thousands of soldiers suffered from tinnitus and severe hearing loss. In 2018, 3M agreed to pay the Department of Justice $9.1 million to settle the allegations without admitting any responsibility.
After the settlement with the federal government, individual service members started suing 3M, claiming that they had tinnitus and/or hearing loss as a result of using the faulty earplugs. Over 230,000 veterans or active military service members are suing 3M. As so many lawsuits with similar complaints had been filed, in 2019 the lawsuits were consolidated under a Florida district court as an MDL to expedite processing and reduce cost and duplication. The 3M earplug MDL is the biggest in US history.
Issue with 3M Combat Arms Earplugs:
In the late 1990s, before 3M acquired the company, U.S. military officials worked with Aearo to produce the reportedly defective 3M earplugs. This led to the creation of a second version of the Combat Arms Earplug (CAEv2). The main aim of CAEv2 was to eliminate the necessity for the soldiers to carry two sets of earplugs. These are dual-ended earplugs that, if worn in one direction, are supposed to block sound like regular earplugs and if worn in the opposite direction, they are meant to block only certain kinds of loud battlefield noise, leaving the wearer able to hear closer, softer sounds.
The CAEv2 earplugs are believed to have an issue with being too short in a certain wearer’s ear canal and fail to create the right seal that would effectively shield the inner ear from the harmful noise.
Is the 3M Earplug Lawsuit a Class Action?
A class action lawsuit is usually when one considers multiple people who have been harmed by a single product made by a single company. A class action lawsuit is the one which is brought on behalf of several plaintiffs who have collectively experienced the same injury. In most cases, they are handled by a single law firm, and any amount obtained is distributed equally among all plaintiffs, irrespective of their individual circumstances.
The 3M earplug lawsuit started out as individual lawsuits. Despite being allegedly brought on by a single product made by a single company, the plaintiffs’ claim the same injuries. The federal court system allowed the MDL process to consolidate the 3M earplug cases that were being filed under one federal court judge who would oversee the litigation’s pretrial phase. One benefit of an MDL settlement over a class action settlement is that each MDL plaintiff will receive a share of the settlement money based on their unique circumstances.
3M Earplug Lawsuit Settlement:
According to Chris Seeger, a primary attorney for the plaintiffs, around 240,000 people are anticipated to be eligible for the more than $6 billion settlement. If less than 98% of the eligible claimants choose to participate, 3M has the option to withdraw from the deal, but Seeger expressed confidence that the threshold would be reached.
According to a statement from the company, about $1 billion will be in the form of 3M stock and the money will be paid from 2023 and 2029. 3M noted that it was not admitting liability with settlement.
After the 3M Earplug Settlement, scams target veterans:
You would think that after the 3M earplug lawsuit had resulted in a settlement of more than $6 billion. Unfortunately, many scammers were attracted by the large amounts of money involved. After the settlement, many veterans received calls from someone claiming to represent the settlement administrator, Archer Systems LLC. Scammers asked for identifying information, such as dates of birth, full social security numbers, claiming that they need the information to check the veteran’s eligibility for the settlement.
On October 14, 2023, the judge issued an order alerting claimants and prospective claimants about the scams. In a ruling, U.S. District Judge M. Casey Rogers made it clear that Archer would never ask for full social security numbers, instructing anyone receiving the calls to notify Archer or the lead plaintiffs’ lawyer, mandated that all plaintiffs’ lawyers provide a copy of the order to their clients, and instructed the court clerk to provide copies to all unrepresented claimants.
The 3M Earplug Lawsuit update on April 1, 2025 is that, In the once-massive 3M earplug MDL, there are only 41 active cases left. The landmark case is finally coming to an end.